• Home
  • About
  • Newsletters
  • Conference
  • TMS Links
  • Calendar
  • Log In
  • Register

Room 151

  • 151 BRIEF

    What's New?

  • London CIV launches sustainable equity fund

    April 19, 2018

  • Council funding boost for stadium for Cornwall

    April 18, 2018

  • Herts creates development joint venture

    April 18, 2018

  • Half of councils ‘draw down on reserves’

    April 18, 2018

  • Northants completes HQ sale

    April 18, 2018

  • Ashford adopts commercial property strategy

    April 18, 2018

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • Agent 151
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Richard Harbord
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
    • Stephen Sheen
  • Interviews
  • Jobs

Barnett formula, LGPS reform and generating revenue

0
  • by James Bevan
  • in Blogs · James Bevan · Recent Posts
  • — 15 Oct, 2014

In squaring the circle of spending and revenue generation, much of the central government attention has been on austerity, yet focusing on cost containment offers no scope for future growth in scale or quality of service provision, whilst demand is ever rising.

 

In a change to James’ regular markets briefing, we asked CCLA’s chief investment officer to reflect on some of the challenges facing local authorities today.

R151: The Scottish referendum had generated much discussion about local authority finance. Where do you think it all leaves the Barnett formula?

JB: In the heat of the debate on Scottish independence, leaders of the main UK political parties committed to sharing “resources equitably across all four nations” and avowed commitment to “the continuation of the Barnett formula” – but it is generally recognised that what was a short-term solution to funding arrangements in the 1970s is now in need of material revision, particularly if tax raising powers are devolved within the UK.

Under the formula, a portion of any additional resources in England are passed as block grant to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, but if an area uses new devolved tax-raising powers, the block grant is reduced by the amount that would have been received for the area of taxation of which they are taking control. The Barnett formula therefore needs to be adjusted to take account of devolution of tax and spending accountability, and not just between regions but also within regions. Meanwhile, the Barnett formula takes no account of factors such as need or density or differential spending within regions although these are often cited as key reasons for it to be maintained.

Yet the Barnett formula is well recognised and any attempt at reform will need to take the public with it involving engagement and transparency and it is likely that there need to be an independent assessment of the fair means of allocating resources raised by the UK government to reflect need, density and population, both between regions and within regions.

R151: Local authority pensions is another area of change. Does it make sense to have passive only pension funds in the LGPS?

JB: Equity investors like the idea of outperforming but recognise that being consistently ahead is very challenging – and active fees often seem to reward the manager and not the risk taker. Passive management has grown in popularity because investors recognise that a properly specified index is hard to beat, and minimising cost-leakage is really important – but investors do reckon that they can do better. Very large funds typically hire a number of active managers, but this practice can quickly become self-defeating, as the effects of the managers pure stock selection skills diversify away rapidly, and the fund is left effectively with a very expensive index fund overlaid with a small number of ‘style tilts’.

Reflecting this challenge, a 2009 performance evaluation study done for the Norwegian sovereign wealth fund came to the conclusion that the fund would be better off simply building a set of Style Factor portfolios themselves. Finance academics and practitioners have long since identified a number of factors that out-perform the broad equity market, on average, over time, and disciplined investors can on paper, with enough time, beat indices quite easily, as indeed can monkeys throwing darts. This is because virtually all ‘price indifferent’ strategies outperform and all non-cap-weighted strategies have value and small size tilts. Yet many active or so-called smart beta strategies under-deliver. The challenges that need to be addressed are high costs, limited scalability and liquidity, low sustainability and poor portfolio construction. If these issues are answered, market cap weighted indexed investing is a poor way forward for pension funds.

R151: Local authorities increasingly look for ways to generate revenues – what opportunities do you think they could explore?

JB: In squaring the circle of spending and revenue generation, much of the central government attention has been on austerity, yet focusing on cost containment offers no scope for future growth in scale or quality of service provision, whilst demand is ever rising. No surprise then that local authorities are increasingly focused on generating revenues, and they look well placed to provide local services on a price-competitive basis with private enterprise, and to work with private enterprise in new form public/private initiatives. On the service front, taking private contract revenue for tasks that local government already provides to the community with a high standard is an obvious opportunity. With private/public initiatives, arguably key wins would be the provision of low cost housing and low carbon energy, serving the needs of communities and also generating revenue.

Local authorities can also enable growth in the private sector. Much is said about the rising tide of self-employment yet for many this is a route forward founded on need not choice, and local authorities could consider providing co-operative-style premises, core business services, and support such as business planning and accountancy, in exchange for a fee and a stake in the future. Truly this would be local authorities helping communities and communities helping local authorities.

James Bevan is chief investment officer of CCLA, specialist fund manager for charities and the public sector. CCLA launched The Public Sector Deposit Fund in 2011 to meet the needs of local authorities and other public sector organisations. You can follow James on twitter @jamesbevan_ccla

Share

You may also like...

  • To boldly go… To boldly go… 1 Jul, 2013
  • Economic and market briefing: UK household incomes Economic and market briefing: UK household incomes 16 Apr, 2012
  • Euroland next steps Euroland next steps 6 Dec, 2011
  • Survey reveals governance concerns Survey reveals governance concerns 5 Mar, 2013

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Register for the Room 151 Weekly Email Digest

  • Latest tweets

    Room 151 3 hours ago

    Herts agrees JV with Morgan Sindall to develop 500 homes: Hertfordshire County Council has signed a deal to create a 50/50 development joint venture with construction firm Morgan Sindall. The council will use its standalone company, Herts Living Ltd… dlvr.it/QQ5ZZg

    Room 151 8 hours ago

    #localgov @JRolfe67 #housing #regeneration twitter.com/SHJFitzgerald/…

    Room 151 8 hours ago

    London CIV launches sustainable equity fund room151.co.uk/brief/#london-… #localgov #lgps

    Room 151 9 hours ago

    #localgov twitter.com/Rebecca_DTZi/s…

    Room 151 10 hours ago

    Newham in danger of missing deadline to publish accounts: The London Borough of Newham is in danger of missing its deadline to publish audited financial statements due to a lack of capacity in its finance team, according to auditors.[...] dlvr.it/QQ3RFn pic.twitter.com/S35NTpUMSJ

    Room 151 12 hours ago

    Enfield funds new housing association with right to buy receipts: The London Borough of Enfield has agreed to fund the creation of a new housing association in which it will take a minority stake, in order to spend £50m of[...] dlvr.it/QQ2hqH pic.twitter.com/Q8Dc5eQuyY

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Council funding boost for stadium for Cornwall room151.co.uk/brief/#council… #infrastructure #development

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Herts creates #development joint venture room151.co.uk/brief/#herts-c… #housing #property

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Half of councils ‘draw down on reserves’ room151.co.uk/brief/#half-of… #localgov #lgps #treasury

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Northants completes HQ sale room151.co.uk/brief/#northam… #localgov

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Ashford adopts commercial #property strategy room151.co.uk/brief/#ashford… #localgov #lgps #housing #treasury

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Government's terms for #businessrates review published room151.co.uk/brief/#terms-f… #localgov #mhclg

    Room 151 1 day ago

    Good chat with LPP's Chris Rule about #LGPS investment in #housing and #regeneration @LPFA1 room151.co.uk/interviews/lgp… #localgov

    Room 151 2 days ago

    #localgov #lgps twitter.com/kshackleton1/s…

    Room 151 2 days ago

    LGPS Pools Roundup: Access appoints Link, CIO for Border to Coast, Central launches funds, new chair for Northern Pool: ACCESS Link wins pooling contract ACCESS  has appointed Link Fund Solutions Ltd to establish and operate its authorised contractual… dlvr.it/QPq8BJ

    Room 151 2 days ago

    Five LGPS funds invest £100m in the private rented sector: Five pension funds agreed last year to commit £100m to a fund aimed at building and managing housing in the private rented sector. Room151 reveals how it came about. The[...] dlvr.it/QPq00D pic.twitter.com/MHjD2vWny2

    Room 151 2 days ago

    Changing the Guard: New Fed leadership and what’s ahead for the world’s most important central bank: Sponsored Article: A change in leadership often sparks intrigue from investors—particularly when the leader is the chair of the world’s most important… dlvr.it/QPpzwx pic.twitter.com/9JWmWJXLzq

    Room 151 2 days ago

    LGPS Q&A: Chris Rule of Local Pensions Partnership on housing and regeneration: Interest in housing and regeneration among institutional investors is growing. In an exclusive interview for Room151, Chris Rule discusses the Local Pensions Partnership’s… dlvr.it/QPpqBS pic.twitter.com/CwuKp8m2ur

    Room 151 2 days ago

    Jeff Houston: LGPS and investment cost transparency: The LGPS Advisory Board has been the first to sign up to a new disclosure template for investment costs. Jeff Houston explains what’s happening and why. It seems a very[...] dlvr.it/QPpq0Y pic.twitter.com/gxW8PinJpX

    Room 151 2 days ago

    Karen Shackleton: The cost conundrum of active managers: LGPS is in a better position to assess the cost of active managers, even if it remains difficult. It is common sense to take costs into account when judging the[...] dlvr.it/QPpfZ1 pic.twitter.com/gfVirgWcy2

  • Categories

    • 151 News
    • Agent 151
    • Blogs
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Development
    • Forum
    • Funding
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O'Donnell
    • Interviews
    • Jackie Shute
    • James Bevan
    • Jobs
    • LGPSi
    • Mark Finnegan
    • Recent Posts
    • Resources
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • Steve Bishop
    • Technical
    • Treasury
  • Archives

    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012
    • 2011
  • Previous story Is a flight to bonds on the cards?
  • Next story Q&A with Jill Davys

© Copyright 2018 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies from this website.OK