• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Conference
  • Events Calendar
  • Webcast151
  • MOTB
  • Log In
  • Register

Room 151

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews

What Argentina can tell us about Greece

0
  • by James Bevan
  • in Blogs · James Bevan · Recent Posts
  • — 9 May, 2012

The plight that Greece, and the rest of Euroland’s periphery for that matter, can be compared with the experience of Argentina from 1999 to 2002, which like the Euroland periphery, reached its debt limits, was pegged to a currency that it could not print (the US dollar) and began to de-leverage.

Looking back, Argentina was initially committed to engaging in austerity and maintaining its dollar currency peg, but eventually the cycle of weak growth, capital flight and rising interest rates overcame the desire to maintain monetary continuity.  As a result, after a 20% contraction in GDP (only a bit more than the contraction that Greece has experienced to date), the Argentinean people overturned the existing government and the currency peg was abandoned.

In terms of the details of Argentina’s experience, when Argentina reached its debt limits, the government initially reacted with austerity and then sought IMF assistance.  When it became clear that Argentina was missing its budget targets and the need for official lending was greater than estimated, the IMF and foreign governments increased their bailout package in exchange for further austerity.  Then when it then became clear that its debt burden was too great, Argentina created a couple of ‘voluntary’ debt swaps to extend maturities and lower interest burdens.  However, without devaluation, this did little to resolve the underlying competitiveness issues, and as the magnitude of the problems became clear to private sector creditors, bank runs occurred, driving up Argentina’s funding needs.  The government subsequently made it illegal to move money out of the country, but these capital controls were both difficult to enforce practically and caused material damage to economic activity, and so were unsuccessful.  In late 2001, the Argentinean president was voted out and a few days later the new administration broke the peg.

One of the key differences between the positions of Greece and Argentina has been the role that the ECB has played, and unlike private creditors, the ECB has continued to provide liquidity to Greece despite its deteriorating creditworthiness and lack of collateral.  This liquidity has allowed Greece to continue to run current account and capital account deficits that would not otherwise have been possible. Without such support, Argentina was forced to enact capital controls and make more rapid economic adjustments. Yet the decline in Greek output is now close to the 20% collapse experienced by Argentina before the peg broke.  Importantly the break of the currency board and the associated monetary easing marked the bottom for Argentina’s economy and it’s interesting that the pace of economic deterioration in late 2001 in Argentina was faster than that experienced in Greece today because the ECB’s actions have slowed the deleveraging, although the current account imbalance in Greece is much worse than that experienced by Argentina.  Even with the improvement of the past few years , driven mostly by the destruction of Greek domestic demand, Greece still has a current account deficit of close to 10% of GDP, far worse than Argentina’s ever was, and Argentina’s current account was in balance by the time it abandoned the peg. However by that time capital flight was the larger problem. Both Greece and Argentina experienced material capital outflows as their economies deteriorated, with the difference of course being that the ECB replaced the outflows from Greece.

Looking at bank deposits, with nearly 25% of deposits fleeing the country, Greece has already experienced a greater bank run than seen with Argentina.  Argentina also experienced a large run on deposits before capital controls were put in place and the peso was eventually devalued and after Argentina’s devaluation, deposits continued to leave the country. The spike in deposits after the devaluation was a function of deposits being redenominated at 1.4 times the previous level, and only after a 75% decline in its currency and high interest rates did deposits stabilize and credit and economic growth resume.

The ECB has printed money to back fill what the private sector withdrew and thereby kept Greece going, but the pursuit of austerity without the prospect of currency devaluation may explain why the collapse in Greek equities has been far worse than that experienced in Argentina.  Devaluation marked the bottom for equities in Argentina, and the market almost doubled in the year after the peg was broken.  Indeed stocks actually rallied in advance of the currency break, likely because markets increasingly expected the currency devaluation and the associated easing of monetary policy. As we know, like Argentina in the early years of the crisis, Greece has experienced basically no improvement in the level of its currency.

The combination of fixed currency and austerity measures means that Greece remains in a destructive de-leveraging phase. The policy mix for dealing with this de-leveraging has not yet been sufficient to alleviate the self-reinforcing deflationary depression. The elections, which largely voted out the parties that agreed to more austerity, highlight the political and economic limitations of austerity when dealing with extreme de-leveraging.

Over the next few months, Greece will be increasingly unlikely to deliver on the austerity commitments it made for its second bailout package and how both the EU and Greece deal with this limitation will likely influence what policy mix the EU utilizes to manage the de-leveraging requirements for other peripheral Euroland countries.

James Bevan is chief investment officer of CCLA, specialist fund manager for charities and the public sector. CCLA launched The Public Sector Deposit Fund in 2011 to meet the needs of local authorities and other public sector organisations. You can follow James on twitter @jamesbevan_ccla

Share

You may also like...

  • Two investment opportunities: challenger banks Vs the bond agency Two investment opportunities: challenger banks Vs the bond agency 11 Jul, 2014
  • James Bevan: Stakes high as Euroland faces five star disruption James Bevan: Stakes high as Euroland faces five star disruption 24 Nov, 2016
  • Tim Richens on LEPs, property and City Deals Tim Richens on LEPs, property and City Deals 14 Aug, 2013
  • Speculators wary of gold bubble Speculators wary of gold bubble 9 Jul, 2013

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Latest tweets

    Room151 2 days ago

    Will new public procurement rules offer the best commercial results?: The government has issued a green paper on reforming procurement rules. Helen Randall and Rebecca Rees examine the proposals and argue they may not go far enough. The Cabinet… dlvr.it/Rqtw6T pic.twitter.com/9GiVTkL08U

    Room151 7 days ago

    The vaccine may help settle cash flows but inflation remains a risk: Sponsored article: Lauren Sewell examines the prospects for long-term borrowing as Brexit settles and vaccines are deployed against Covid-19. On the 9th October 2019 Whitehall sent… dlvr.it/RqZXCr pic.twitter.com/PzgOZOGQ0k

    Room151 7 days ago

    ESG in liquidity: Sponsored article: Gavin Haywood looks at the integration of ESG in Federated Hermes’ money market funds. Federated Hermes has over 300 public sector clients invested in our AAA rated money[...] dlvr.it/RqZX5f pic.twitter.com/E87sBXsay8

    Room151 1 week ago

    New realities of investing cash and liquidity: “What to do now?”: Sponsored article: Brian Buck looks at the “unique challenge” for cash management strategies. As investors assess the ongoing impact of the pandemic on their business, levels of cash and… dlvr.it/RqVbk9 pic.twitter.com/ZElVASmEUV

    Room151 1 week ago

    Extra finance promised by the government receives a broad welcome: Sponsored article: The financial pressures facing local authorities this year continue to pose challenges for council treasurers. While the launch of the UK’s Covid-19 vaccination… dlvr.it/RqTzTF pic.twitter.com/HCjH0pyHR5

    Room151 1 week ago

    A savvy approach to managing your cash: Sponsored article: Caroline Hedges examines the need for active cash management to achieve a higher than average return. Last year saw the already mountainous pile of negative-yielding debt around the[...] dlvr.it/RqTzMK pic.twitter.com/uP0RQYTJLt

    Room151 1 week ago

    Putting alternatives at the heart of multi-asset portfolios: Sponsored article: Nick Edwardson looks at the assets that provide the “most attractive opportunities”. We believe that asset allocation is the primary driver of investment returns and that the… dlvr.it/RqQ2Qt pic.twitter.com/WLBzvRRRUQ

    Room151 1 week ago

    Thriving in the pandemic: Avoiding the stragglers: Sponsored article: George Crowdy looks at the sectors providing opportunities for sustainable investment. Throughout much of 2020, we talked about why sustainable investing has thrived in the pandemic,… dlvr.it/RqQ2NQ pic.twitter.com/dxiPWKFsPl

    Room151 1 week ago

    The development of CCLA’s mental health benchmark: Sponsored article: Amy Browne examines the importance of investing in mental health in the workplace. We are living through a public health emergency in more ways than one. Physical health[...] dlvr.it/RqQ2Jx pic.twitter.com/o6yRSCX3oF

    Room151 1 week ago

    Brexit: What the EU trade deal means for the UK economy: Sponsored article: Hetal Mehta looks at the impact of Brexit on economic prospects. Four and a half years after voting to leave the EU, on Christmas Eve the UK finally[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDt pic.twitter.com/No62srfE8h

    Room151 1 week ago

    Cash dethroned: The quest for liquid yield: Sponsored article: Peter Hunt and George Carne ask how treasury departments can balance the need for yield and liquidity. The massive stimulus and waves of liquidity provided by central banks[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDj pic.twitter.com/05g6Zhu1kU

    Room151 1 week ago

    Richard Harbord: Delayed “capital determinations” make section 25 opinions a new crunch point: The severe pressure on local government budgets now means section 151 officers confront a tricky call on  whether they can make a judgement on the robustness… dlvr.it/RqLBDV pic.twitter.com/vTAbDKFzkI

    Room151 1 month ago

    PWLB Consultation: Analysis straight from Dickens: Helen Radall and Paul McDermott present a legal examination of the new PWLB borrowing rules as Charles Dickens might have imagined it. Free and easy PWLB (“Marley” to his friends)[...] dlvr.it/RnmwLq pic.twitter.com/yFxcPrQqEG

    Room151 1 month ago

    Room151’s top stories from a momentous year: 2020 was the year in which local government grappled with Covid-19, funding strains, controversy over borrowing rules and the threat of financial collapse. It has been an exhausting and historic[...] dlvr.it/RnlpZg pic.twitter.com/g3myNyox6J

    Room151 1 month ago

    Tracy Bingham: 2020, a year best forgotten but also one of learning: Many will rush to erase 2020 from their memories but, writes Tracy Bingham, there were also many lessons about finance teams, strategic planning and leadership. 2020: A year we’d… dlvr.it/RnlpY2 pic.twitter.com/m7G1krrtCu

    Room151 1 month ago

    Settlement must address ‘precarious’ local government finances: Dan Bates crosses his fingers for “no nasty surprises” in this week’s funding settlement but argues the “bigger prize” is post-Covid financial certainty. Thursday (17 December) should be the… dlvr.it/Rnj9dG pic.twitter.com/KLKjjuBqJE

    Room151 1 month ago

    PWLB consultation: Big change on the way but there are ‘grey areas’ and opportunities: The consultation on PWLB borrowing has concluded creating a new landscape for funding property acquisition. Our experts look at the implications. Tracie Langley The… dlvr.it/RndRvJ pic.twitter.com/KEqXEBmEfq

  • Categories

    • 151 News
    • Agent 151
    • Blogs
    • Chris Buss
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • Dan Bates
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Development
    • Forum
    • Funding
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O'Donnell
    • Interviews
    • Jackie Shute
    • James Bevan
    • Jobs
    • LGPSi
    • Mark Finnegan
    • Recent Posts
    • Resources
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Fitzgerald
    • Stephen Sheen
    • Steve Bishop
    • Technical
    • Treasury
    • Uncategorized
  • Archives

    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012
    • 2011
  • Previous story Consequences of Greek turmoil
  • Next story Mark Sheldon on ERP, procurement and “growing the business”

© Copyright 2021 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies from this website.OK