• Home
  • About
  • 151 IMPACT AWARDS
  • Subscribe
  • Conference
  • Events Calendar
  • Webcast151
  • MOTB
  • Log In
  • Register

Room 151

Impact Awards –>
  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews

£5bn in hidden underperformance from alternatives in LGPS revealed

0
  • by Guest
  • in LGPSi
  • — 9 Oct, 2014

Henrik Pedersen is managing partner of Clerus who have this week published a paper on alternative investment performance in the LGPS.

Alternative assets such as hedge funds and Diversified Growth Funds (DGFs) are typically promoted by investment consultants as a vehicle to achieve equity-like returns, but with only a proportion of the risk. However, according to Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) annual reports and investment principles issued over the last year, an estimated £20bn of alternative assets is being benchmarked against cash-like return across LGPS.

This includes 100% of DGFs, 100% of hedge funds and 90% of infrastructure funds.This choice of benchmark is inappropriate because it seriously understates the risk of these assets and the equity-like returns being expected by pension funds.

Hiding Poor Performance
Our report released this week quantifies the performance impact on scheme benchmarks, had more appropriate equity-like benchmarks been used over the last decade.  This is important because a typical allocation to alternative assets will be accompanied by a reduction in the expected return of the scheme specific benchmark. This happens because a percentage of assets are allocated from equities, or bonds, into lower yielding cash or cash plus investments.

The reduction in benchmark performance is estimated at 0.5% per annum or £5bn in today’s money for all LGPS. This estimate excludes fees paid to advisors for manager selection and monitoring, transition costs and incentive fees paid to managers for below target returns.  The underperformance from alternative assets versus expected returns is hidden, because most LGPS only monitor and report on investment performance versus scheme specific benchmarks, but do not measure or report on the performance of asset allocation decisions (i.e. benchmark changes).

Reducing benchmark returns does not in itself lower overall fund performance. However the alternative investments recommended to LGPS over the last decade did not produce equity-like returns. Instead the combined investments produced lower net returns than equities and bonds, a result that could have been achieved by simple de-risking at a fraction of the cost.

Spotlight on Governance
This highlights a serious governance issue. The use of misleading performance metrics raises important professional and ethical questions. It also undermines basic performance assessment principles and leads to excess fees (including potential performance fees) being paid to investment managers for longer as their performance looks better than it is and cannot be assessed correctly.

We must also question why investment consultants are promoting these products as providing equity-like returns, but recommending that they are benchmarked and remunerated against cash-like benchmarks. This principle is no different to measuring an active equity manager against a cash benchmark instead of an equities index.

Unfortunately this has created an artificial situation where both schemes and consultants are able to report above benchmark performance from their manager selection and asset allocation activities even if overall performance was reduced and deficits increased.

Recommendations
Our report recommends that local authorities invest to acquire the expertise to challenge and review the advice they receive from their consultant and to improve existing performance benchmarks. The pay-back in improved governance and transparency will be fast and any costs will be far outweighed by the benefits of lower fees and better investment returns.

Link to LGPS reform
These findings place another huge question mark against the LGPS reform proposals. Why would the LGPS want to be in a position where they were paying £301m of annual fees, and 58% of total fees, to an 11.5% allocation to alternative investments expected to produce such low cash-like returns?

Photo: “Numbers And Finance” by Ken Teegardin 

Share

You may also like...

  • Transparency project begins to shine a light on LGPS costs 23 Jul, 2020
  • LGPS pooling prompts investment in social property fund LGPS pooling prompts investment in social property fund 4 Aug, 2016
  • LGPS pools miss opportunity to ‘consolidate’ sub-funds LGPS pools miss opportunity to ‘consolidate’ sub-funds 30 Aug, 2018
  • Pension pool CIO resigns after less than a month Pension pool CIO resigns after less than a month 25 Sep, 2019

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Latest tweets

    Room151 18 hours ago

    Impact Awards: Liverpool’s cafe culture and Warrington’s investment in homes: The CCLA/Room151 Impact Awards showcase  finance teams with a direct impact on their local communities and the environment. This week we spotlight Liverpool City Council’s… dlvr.it/RxJsKb pic.twitter.com/dEYpaz6HP0

    Room151 21 hours ago

    Doing something in #localgov #finance for housing or regeneration? Check out the 'Place Shaping' category room151.co.uk/impact-awards/… sponsored by @31tenConsulting in the CCLA/Room151 Impact Awards. #timetoenter !! pic.twitter.com/dU99vE6Wws

    Room151 2 days ago

    Doing something in #localgov #finance for Adult Social Care & Health? Check out the ASC&H category room151.co.uk/impact-awards/… sponsored by Fundamentum Social Housing REIT in the CCLA/Room151 Impact Awards. #timetoenter !!

    Room151 2 days ago

    Doing something in #localgov #finance for the environment? Check out the 'carbon management' category room151.co.uk/impact-awards/… sponsored by @ACSLLP in the CCLA/Room151 Impact Awards. #timetoenter !!

    Room151 2 days ago

    So what are the seven categories for the CCLA/Room151 Impact Awards? Here they are room151.co.uk/impact-awards/… #localgov #finance #outcomes

    Room151 2 days ago

    Why should LGPS be concerned about rising inflation?: The impact of the coronavirus pandemic, lockdown and wider economic uncertainty created  deflationary pressures which raise important considerations for the Local Government Pension Scheme writes… dlvr.it/RxF7Fs pic.twitter.com/JlcjROBIpz

    Room151 3 days ago

    JOB ALERT: LPFA Finance Director vacancy: London Pensions Fund Authority Finance Director and s151 Officer Competitive salary and benefits The largest Local Government Pension (LGPS) provider in London with around £6.5 billion of assets and 135[...] dlvr.it/RxBdJP

    Room151 3 days ago

    Richard Harbord: Further signs that local government finance is failing: The crisis in Liverpool and a fix for education budgets are further indication that local government finance is in need of a root and branch review. Even for those students[...] dlvr.it/Rx9PSV pic.twitter.com/sAanC2gEyu

    Room151 1 week ago

    Impact Awards: Finance helps launch school meals company and support business during lockdown: The CCLA/Room151 Impact Awards will showcase the way finance teams have a direct impact on their local communities and the environment. This week we spotlight… dlvr.it/RwnlF4 pic.twitter.com/AJhne1MVG4

    Room151 1 week ago

    "This work has made a vital, practical contribution to ensuring people have been supported through the pandemic." #impact #151awards #covid #s151 room151.co.uk/treasury/impac… #impactcasestudies #councilfinancemakesadifference

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    room151.co.uk/impact-awards/ #passiton #localgov #s151 #151awards pic.twitter.com/A0uO0dwBkM

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Financial pressures loom for 2023 and beyond: Kate Ogden writes the government has addressed most of the short-term Covid-19 financial pressures facing English councils, but problems loom in 2022-23 and the years following. As we enter the[...] dlvr.it/RwfDsz pic.twitter.com/hpv2R09w75

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Calling all #localgov finance officers and #s151s room151.co.uk/impact-awards/ It's the #151Awards Thanks to the @LGALocalism for helping us get the word out along with all the LA treasury societies. pic.twitter.com/Nkal9BrH1J

  • Categories

    • 151 News
    • Agent 151
    • Blogs
    • Chris Buss
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • Dan Bates
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Development
    • Forum
    • Funding
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O'Donnell
    • Interviews
    • Jackie Shute
    • James Bevan
    • Jobs
    • LGPSi
    • Mark Finnegan
    • Recent Posts
    • Resources
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Fitzgerald
    • Stephen Sheen
    • Steve Bishop
    • Technical
    • Treasury
    • Uncategorized
  • Archives

    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012
    • 2011
  • Previous story Boris on LGPS, LPFA equities move, Angus audit “waste of money”, Dorset partnership
  • Next story Is a flight to bonds on the cards?

© Copyright 2021 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.