• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • LATIF
  • Conferences
  • Dashboard
  • Edit My Profile
  • Log In
  • Logout
  • Register
  • Edit this post

Room 151

  • 151 BRIEF

    What's New?

  • Slough welcomes commitment that Office for Local Government ‘will not be a burden’

    June 30, 2022

  • Homes England agrees strategic partnership with two authorities

    June 29, 2022

  • Soaring inflation and pay pressures to add £3.6bn to council budgets

    June 28, 2022

  • Underfunded social care reforms could ‘exacerbate workforce pressures’

    June 27, 2022

  • Nottingham City Council leader labels proposed intervention as ‘disappointing’

    June 27, 2022

  • Government preparing to intervene in Nottingham City Council

    June 23, 2022

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews
  • Briefs

£5bn in hidden underperformance from alternatives in LGPS revealed

0
  • by Guest
  • in LGPS
  • — 9 Oct, 2014

Henrik Pedersen is managing partner of Clerus who have this week published a paper on alternative investment performance in the LGPS.

Alternative assets such as hedge funds and Diversified Growth Funds (DGFs) are typically promoted by investment consultants as a vehicle to achieve equity-like returns, but with only a proportion of the risk. However, according to Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) annual reports and investment principles issued over the last year, an estimated £20bn of alternative assets is being benchmarked against cash-like return across LGPS.

This includes 100% of DGFs, 100% of hedge funds and 90% of infrastructure funds.This choice of benchmark is inappropriate because it seriously understates the risk of these assets and the equity-like returns being expected by pension funds.

Hiding Poor Performance
Our report released this week quantifies the performance impact on scheme benchmarks, had more appropriate equity-like benchmarks been used over the last decade.  This is important because a typical allocation to alternative assets will be accompanied by a reduction in the expected return of the scheme specific benchmark. This happens because a percentage of assets are allocated from equities, or bonds, into lower yielding cash or cash plus investments.

The reduction in benchmark performance is estimated at 0.5% per annum or £5bn in today’s money for all LGPS. This estimate excludes fees paid to advisors for manager selection and monitoring, transition costs and incentive fees paid to managers for below target returns.  The underperformance from alternative assets versus expected returns is hidden, because most LGPS only monitor and report on investment performance versus scheme specific benchmarks, but do not measure or report on the performance of asset allocation decisions (i.e. benchmark changes).

Reducing benchmark returns does not in itself lower overall fund performance. However the alternative investments recommended to LGPS over the last decade did not produce equity-like returns. Instead the combined investments produced lower net returns than equities and bonds, a result that could have been achieved by simple de-risking at a fraction of the cost.

Spotlight on Governance
This highlights a serious governance issue. The use of misleading performance metrics raises important professional and ethical questions. It also undermines basic performance assessment principles and leads to excess fees (including potential performance fees) being paid to investment managers for longer as their performance looks better than it is and cannot be assessed correctly.

We must also question why investment consultants are promoting these products as providing equity-like returns, but recommending that they are benchmarked and remunerated against cash-like benchmarks. This principle is no different to measuring an active equity manager against a cash benchmark instead of an equities index.

Unfortunately this has created an artificial situation where both schemes and consultants are able to report above benchmark performance from their manager selection and asset allocation activities even if overall performance was reduced and deficits increased.

Recommendations
Our report recommends that local authorities invest to acquire the expertise to challenge and review the advice they receive from their consultant and to improve existing performance benchmarks. The pay-back in improved governance and transparency will be fast and any costs will be far outweighed by the benefits of lower fees and better investment returns.

Link to LGPS reform
These findings place another huge question mark against the LGPS reform proposals. Why would the LGPS want to be in a position where they were paying £301m of annual fees, and 58% of total fees, to an 11.5% allocation to alternative investments expected to produce such low cash-like returns?

Photo: “Numbers And Finance” by Ken Teegardin 

Share

You may also like...

  • Why build to rent has remained resilient despite Covid-19 28th Apr, 2021
  • LGPS funds seeking to divest from Russia 3rd Mar, 2022
  • LGPS: responding to the new normal 8th Mar, 2022
  • Cryptocurrencies: Are they an asset class for LGPS funds? 6th Jul, 2021

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • 151 BRIEFS – WHAT’s NEW?

    • Homes England agrees strategic partnership with two authorities
    • Soaring inflation and pay pressures to add £3.6bn to council budgets
    • Underfunded social care reforms could ‘exacerbate workforce pressures’
    • Nottingham City Council leader labels proposed intervention as ‘disappointing’
    • Government preparing to intervene in Nottingham City Council
  • Room151’s LGPS Roundtables

    Biodiversity
    Valuations & Risk
    LGPS Women

  • Room151’s LGPS Roundtables

    Biodiversity
    LGPS Women
    Valuations & Risk
  • Latest tweets

    Room151 17 hours ago

    Hillier confirmed as keynote speaker for LATIF/FDs’ Summit: Dame Meg Hillier, chair of the Public Accounts Committee, has been confirmed as a keynote speaker for Room151’s combined Local Authority Treasurers Investment Forum (LATIF) and FDs Summit. The… dlvr.it/ST70F7 pic.twitter.com/hxV676Iley

    Room151 17 hours ago

    Councils’ funding at risk due to ‘undercounting’ in census data: Population estimates in London and Manchester may have been significantly underestimated in the 2021 census potentially threatening government funding for frontline services in these… dlvr.it/ST707J pic.twitter.com/VncIyaXa01

    Room151 3 days ago

    Gove at LGA: councils to receive two-year financial settlement: Michael Gove has announced that councils will receive a two-year financial settlement from next year to provide authorities with “financial certainty” and allow them to plan ahead. The… dlvr.it/ST0kSV pic.twitter.com/wxL3UM4sGO

    Room151 3 days ago

    LGPS valuations: the digital journey: Rob Bilton explains how technology is helping to deliver one of the most complex data exercises in the world of public sector pensions. The 2022 valuations for LGPS funds in[...] dlvr.it/ST0kMq pic.twitter.com/VxjSPC2Uvo

    Room151 7 days ago

    Conrad Hall: ‘more sophisticated’ regulation needed for local government: The chair of the CIPFA/LASAAC Code Board has questioned the sophistication of financial regulation in local government and the continuing focus of the Department for Levelling Up,… dlvr.it/SSnPBV pic.twitter.com/G5d7JCWF8c

    Room151 1 week ago

    Slough Council approves plans to restructure finance department: Slough Borough Council has approved plans to restructure its finance department to enhance capacity and capability and to address a “significant weakness” in the function. The local… dlvr.it/SSf8DG pic.twitter.com/l5lmyHmkBg

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Previous story Boris on LGPS, LPFA equities move, Angus audit “waste of money”, Dorset partnership
  • Next story Is a flight to bonds on the cards?

© Copyright 2022 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

0 shares