• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Conference
  • Events Calendar
  • Webcast151
  • MOTB
  • Log In
  • Register

Room 151

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews

John Raisin: Pension contributions – one size doesn’t fit all

0
  • by Guest
  • in LGPSi
  • — 30 Jan, 2019

John Raisin takes issue with a recent suggestion that the variety of actuarial assumptions needs to be eliminated.

In a recent Room 151 article, a finance director argued in favour of standardising actuarial assumptions across the LGPS to reduce pension costs and free up resources for other purposes.  As a former CFO of two local authorities (a London Borough and a County), I understand the budget pressures that councils are under, and can see how pensions may seem an obvious place to find savings.  However, pensions are long-term and complex. Seeking to standardise actuarial assumptions is not, in my view, the best way for LGPS employers to get good value from their pension contributions.

The director is correct that LGPS contributions can vary significantly for different employers, sometimes in counter-intuitive ways.  In the example he cited, one district council was paying lower contributions than another despite having a much larger deficit.  The suggestion was that the council with the bigger deficit was getting a better deal out of its LGPS Fund because it was paying £1m per year less in pension contributions which it could therefore “spend on local services”.

A Date for Your Diary
Room151’s LGPS Asset Allocation Forum
November 7th, 2019, The London Stock Exchange
Register your interest…

This approach is somewhat one-dimensional and is certainly too simplistic. Whatever actuarial assumptions are used, employees’ benefits have to be paid for eventually. Paying less now simply means paying more later on. Worse, by missing out on investment returns on that £1m, the council is potentially passing on a bigger problem and more cuts to future taxpayers and a future CFO!

I do not know the details behind the example, and there may be very good reasons why the second fund in question can accept lower contributions. For example, it may be relying more on investment returns, or it may be giving the council more time to repay its deficit: either of these suggests a greater risk appetite, which will not be the case with all funds and councils.

Individual employer membership can also be very important, and factors such as age, service and pay profile could all affect contributions. The quality of data submitted by each individual employer will affect the actuary’s calculation of its liabilities and can therefore influence employer pension contributions. Councils who heavily outsource services will appear to have lower pension contributions as a percentage of their budget because the pension costs for the outsourced staff will be hidden in the fees paid to contractors. This could be misleading if in reality the council is still ultimately responsible for funding those benefits.

But what about the actuarial assumptions themselves? Is there an argument to standardise these?  The Government Actuary’s Department’s (GAD) recent review of the 2016 LGPS valuations recommended “greater clarity and consistency in actuarial assumptions, except where differences are justified by material local variations”.  However, for most assumptions there are quite clearly “material local variations”.  Some Councils have different service delivery models which affect pay levels. A shire county may see their members live much longer than some metropolitan or London boroughs, and investment returns vary significantly depending on how funds invest their assets.

The present situation where each actuarial firm has its own methodology for asset returns (for example setting a discount rate) means that when selecting their actuary this factor, along with a range of other issues, can be taken into account. This allows the fund to appoint an actuary it can work with to best reflect its circumstances, strategies and policies. Additionally, there is no such thing as a “correct” discount rate. Consequently, if a common discount rate was applied to all LGPS fund valuations it would just be the view of one organisation – most likely GAD.

Far from being a problem, the ability of each fund to use its own judgement and adapt to local circumstances is one of the LGPS’s greatest strengths. It is far more in the spirit of localism that each fund can choose its own actuary and come up with its own local approach, than be forced to adopt an inflexible standardised method formulated by central government. The four actuarial firms who work with the LGPS understand the scheme and work with the individual funds to apply solutions which are tailored to their local circumstances, strategies and policies.

Furthermore, the presence of four actuarial firms offering their services to the LGPS provides competition and means they continue to evolve and improve their approach and techniques in relation to the scheme. This leads to the LGPS obtaining both greater input and value from its actuarial advisors. If we move to GAD stipulated assumptions, then this would reduce both the ability and the incentive for the actuarial firms to innovate and respond to the ever-changing circumstances of both the LGPS and individual employers in the scheme.

Finally, in contrast to the LGPS, consider the unhappy position of the unfunded central government schemes (eg the NHS, teachers, and firefighters). Each of the unfunded schemes uses a single set of assumptions across the whole country, and all their employers pay the same contribution rate. Without any assets to help absorb the impact of changing assumptions, and without any flexibility to reflect differences between employers, the contributions required by these schemes can change wildly every time they are reviewed.

Employers of teachers across England and Wales are facing contribution increases of more than 40% from September this year and they are at the lower end of the increases among the unfunded schemes! Could LGPS employers as a whole afford increases of over 40% in their employer contributions at the 2019 actuarial valuation? Such a scenario is however most unlikely, due to the local discretion afforded by the present LGPS actuarial arrangements.

The LGPS is not perfect, and some funds could do a better job of explaining and consulting with employers at each valuation. It is, however, also essential that the finance directors of employers within each fund fully engage with the administering authority to understand and appreciate the unique characteristics of their circumstances. Surely, it is much better that conversations take place at a local level reflecting local differences, rather than relying on a one size fits all direction from central government!

John Raisin is presently Independent Advisor to three LGPS Funds and Independent Chair of the Merseyside LGPS Pension Board. Previously, he was Chief Finance Officer of both a London Borough and a County Council.

Get the LGPS Quarterly Briefing

Share

You may also like...

  • Investment returns before morals, concludes QC Investment returns before morals, concludes QC 10 Apr, 2014
  • Are LGPS assets in safe hands? Are LGPS assets in safe hands? 26 Mar, 2013
  • Fund manager to focus LGPS resource at pool level Fund manager to focus LGPS resource at pool level 31 Aug, 2017
  • William Bourne: Will private equity remain attractive to LGPS? 13 May, 2020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Latest tweets

    Room151 6 hours ago

    The vaccine may help settle cash flows but inflation remains a risk: Sponsored article: Lauren Sewell examines the prospects for long-term borrowing as Brexit settles and vaccines are deployed against Covid-19. On the 9th October 2019 Whitehall sent… dlvr.it/RqZXCr pic.twitter.com/PzgOZOGQ0k

    Room151 6 hours ago

    ESG in liquidity: Sponsored article: Gavin Haywood looks at the integration of ESG in Federated Hermes’ money market funds. Federated Hermes has over 300 public sector clients invested in our AAA rated money[...] dlvr.it/RqZX5f pic.twitter.com/E87sBXsay8

    Room151 1 day ago

    New realities of investing cash and liquidity: “What to do now?”: Sponsored article: Brian Buck looks at the “unique challenge” for cash management strategies. As investors assess the ongoing impact of the pandemic on their business, levels of cash and… dlvr.it/RqVbk9 pic.twitter.com/ZElVASmEUV

    Room151 1 day ago

    Extra finance promised by the government receives a broad welcome: Sponsored article: The financial pressures facing local authorities this year continue to pose challenges for council treasurers. While the launch of the UK’s Covid-19 vaccination… dlvr.it/RqTzTF pic.twitter.com/HCjH0pyHR5

    Room151 1 day ago

    A savvy approach to managing your cash: Sponsored article: Caroline Hedges examines the need for active cash management to achieve a higher than average return. Last year saw the already mountainous pile of negative-yielding debt around the[...] dlvr.it/RqTzMK pic.twitter.com/uP0RQYTJLt

    Room151 2 days ago

    Putting alternatives at the heart of multi-asset portfolios: Sponsored article: Nick Edwardson looks at the assets that provide the “most attractive opportunities”. We believe that asset allocation is the primary driver of investment returns and that the… dlvr.it/RqQ2Qt pic.twitter.com/WLBzvRRRUQ

    Room151 2 days ago

    Thriving in the pandemic: Avoiding the stragglers: Sponsored article: George Crowdy looks at the sectors providing opportunities for sustainable investment. Throughout much of 2020, we talked about why sustainable investing has thrived in the pandemic,… dlvr.it/RqQ2NQ pic.twitter.com/dxiPWKFsPl

    Room151 2 days ago

    The development of CCLA’s mental health benchmark: Sponsored article: Amy Browne examines the importance of investing in mental health in the workplace. We are living through a public health emergency in more ways than one. Physical health[...] dlvr.it/RqQ2Jx pic.twitter.com/o6yRSCX3oF

    Room151 3 days ago

    Brexit: What the EU trade deal means for the UK economy: Sponsored article: Hetal Mehta looks at the impact of Brexit on economic prospects. Four and a half years after voting to leave the EU, on Christmas Eve the UK finally[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDt pic.twitter.com/No62srfE8h

    Room151 3 days ago

    Cash dethroned: The quest for liquid yield: Sponsored article: Peter Hunt and George Carne ask how treasury departments can balance the need for yield and liquidity. The massive stimulus and waves of liquidity provided by central banks[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDj pic.twitter.com/05g6Zhu1kU

    Room151 3 days ago

    Richard Harbord: Delayed “capital determinations” make section 25 opinions a new crunch point: The severe pressure on local government budgets now means section 151 officers confront a tricky call on  whether they can make a judgement on the robustness… dlvr.it/RqLBDV pic.twitter.com/vTAbDKFzkI

    Room151 4 weeks ago

    PWLB Consultation: Analysis straight from Dickens: Helen Radall and Paul McDermott present a legal examination of the new PWLB borrowing rules as Charles Dickens might have imagined it. Free and easy PWLB (“Marley” to his friends)[...] dlvr.it/RnmwLq pic.twitter.com/yFxcPrQqEG

    Room151 4 weeks ago

    Room151’s top stories from a momentous year: 2020 was the year in which local government grappled with Covid-19, funding strains, controversy over borrowing rules and the threat of financial collapse. It has been an exhausting and historic[...] dlvr.it/RnlpZg pic.twitter.com/g3myNyox6J

    Room151 4 weeks ago

    Tracy Bingham: 2020, a year best forgotten but also one of learning: Many will rush to erase 2020 from their memories but, writes Tracy Bingham, there were also many lessons about finance teams, strategic planning and leadership. 2020: A year we’d… dlvr.it/RnlpY2 pic.twitter.com/m7G1krrtCu

    Room151 1 month ago

    Settlement must address ‘precarious’ local government finances: Dan Bates crosses his fingers for “no nasty surprises” in this week’s funding settlement but argues the “bigger prize” is post-Covid financial certainty. Thursday (17 December) should be the… dlvr.it/Rnj9dG pic.twitter.com/KLKjjuBqJE

    Room151 1 month ago

    PWLB consultation: Big change on the way but there are ‘grey areas’ and opportunities: The consultation on PWLB borrowing has concluded creating a new landscape for funding property acquisition. Our experts look at the implications. Tracie Langley The… dlvr.it/RndRvJ pic.twitter.com/KEqXEBmEfq

    Room151 1 month ago

    2021: Better income outcomes?: Sponsored article: Investors should be mindful of structural challenges posed to income generation as a result of rapid thematic change. Jon Bell looks at the prospects for the coming year.[...] dlvr.it/RndRsw pic.twitter.com/TxVk8aXkMq

  • Categories

    • 151 News
    • Agent 151
    • Blogs
    • Chris Buss
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • Dan Bates
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Development
    • Forum
    • Funding
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O'Donnell
    • Interviews
    • Jackie Shute
    • James Bevan
    • Jobs
    • LGPSi
    • Mark Finnegan
    • Recent Posts
    • Resources
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Fitzgerald
    • Stephen Sheen
    • Steve Bishop
    • Technical
    • Treasury
    • Uncategorized
  • Archives

    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012
    • 2011
  • Previous story Chris Bilsland: 2019 promises to be eventful for the LGPS
  • Next story LGPS Q&A – David Walker of Hymans Robertson on the triennial valuation

© Copyright 2021 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies from this website.OK