• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Conference
  • Events Calendar
  • Webcast151
  • MOTB
  • Log In
  • Register

Room 151

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews

John Harrison: Alternative investments under fire

0
  • by John Harrison
  • in LGPSi
  • — 3 Dec, 2014

LGPS funds on average have retained a far higher allocation to equities than other UK pension funds or international institutional investors, so it is misleading to suggest they have been bamboozled by their consultants into over-diversifying into alternatives.

John Harrison is Director, Multi-Asset at Henderson Global Investors and Independent Investment Adviser to the Surrey County Council pension fund. 

The recent CLERUS report on the mis-selling of alternative investments by consultants[1] has attracted significant press attention. That was probably the intention given the provocative language used in the report and the desire of the authors to profile CLERUS’ services in reviewing advisor recommendations. Headlines are cheaper than advertising after all. But is there any substance to the report’s accusation that consultants have hoodwinked the local government pension scheme (LGPS) into buying alternatives on false information?

It is important to state at the outset that I am not independent on this issue – very few people with LGPS investment experience are. Over the last 30 years I have managed, advised, and consulted to a wide range of LGPS funds. It is this experience that leads me to challenge the CLERUS conclusions, which in my view are overstated and largely unfair.

The report does highlight one risk within the strategy-setting process – the potentially spurious ‘science’ of asset allocation modelling. No one can know with accuracy what future returns and volatility will be from any ‘risk’ asset, let alone the correlations between them. We are therefore forced to use the past as an imperfect guide and make educated guesses about how this may change in future. For traditional asset classes we can look back over decades of past data to see how the relationships change over time. Alternatives have less of a history and therefore require bigger and possibly less educated guesses.

But have consultants abused this process by biasing the inputs to suit their business interests – the central accusation made in the report? This is much harder to prove. There is a plethora of academic evidence that diversification across asset classes dampens volatility and improves risk-adjusted returns. It is therefore entirely justifiable to assume a better risk-adjusted return from a diversified portfolio than from a single asset class.

The problem is in defining how significant this benefit will be looking forward, especially as the relationships between asset classes can change very quickly. In my experience, consultants do at times assume overly optimistic risk/return characteristics for alternatives. The easy way to identify this is to ask the consultant what their model’s optimum allocation to alternatives would be if they did not impose an arbitrary upper limit. If it is a very high number, it suggests the model’s inputs are flawed.

But the accusation is deeper. It implies that LGPS funds have moved into alternatives purely because they have naively followed their consultant’s strategy models and have suffered a performance cost as a result. That is excessively simplistic. The growing use of alternatives reflects several factors – the desire to exploit illiquidity premiums (private equity), to offset inflation risks (infrastructure), or to dampen volatility (hedge funds and diversified growth funds or DGFs). Given the rollercoaster ride from equity markets in recent years it is hardly surprising LGPS funds are looking for ways to generate the returns they need more consistently. LGPS funds on average have retained a far higher allocation to equities than other UK pension funds or international institutional investors, so it is misleading to suggest they have been bamboozled by their consultants into over-diversifying into alternatives.

Similarly, it is misleading to suggest that cash-plus benchmarks have been selected to hide the resultant performance shortfall or make incentive fees easier to achieve. The report highlighted hedge funds and DGFs in particular as using cash-like benchmarks. Hedge funds often have limited correlation with market direction (which is why investors own them) so a cash plus benchmark is not unreasonable as a basis for performance fees. Returns from DGFs, by contrast, are likely to be more closely correlated with market direction, but I do not know of a single LGPS fund that pays a performance fee on a DGF based on the cash-plus benchmark.

The LGPS faces many challenges in closing funding deficits. Diversification will be one of the tools that will help them achieve this. Ignoring alternatives probably will not.

[1] CLERUS, 2014. Mis-selling of Alternatives by Investment Consultants? A Review of Methods used to Promote Alternatives and Dress-up Performance, [pdf] CLERUS. Available here.

Share

You may also like...

  • The case for Japanese equities The case for Japanese equities 5 Apr, 2012
  • LGPS funds warned to review cost of active managers LGPS funds warned to review cost of active managers 1 Feb, 2018
  • LPFA wins big with Buffet-style stock picking LPFA wins big with Buffet-style stock picking 28 Jul, 2016
  • Tony Williams: McCloud case and implications for the LGPS? Tony Williams: McCloud case and implications for the LGPS? 22 Jul, 2019

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Latest tweets

    Room151 6 hours ago

    PWLB changes and local authority creditworthiness: David Green asks whether new borrowing rules should prompt lenders to reassess the risk of doing business with councils. There are two main reasons why an organisation might default on[...] dlvr.it/RrRqq1 pic.twitter.com/ZY9gpuPBbu

    Room151 2 days ago

    All three days of #LATIF & FDs' Summit are available on our webcast channel gotostage.com/channel/room151

    Room151 5 days ago

    FDs’ Summit experts defend councils as MPs label property investment ‘risky’: As Room151’s FDs’ Summit conference explores local government’s investment in commercial property MPs once again lable it a “significant risk to government”. Once again MPs… dlvr.it/Rr7lZx pic.twitter.com/jPvcZjDAS4

    Room151 5 days ago

    Global macro outlook: Virus versus vaccine: Sponsored article: Salman Ahmed argues monetary policy, a global vaccine rollout and fiscal stimulus are likely to put “upward pressure” on bond yields. Much like the latter half of 2020,[...] dlvr.it/Rr60nt pic.twitter.com/qsymBWmKmV

    Room151 6 days ago

    ‘Chasing yield’ not the best strategy as negative rates loom: Recent speculation that the UK may be heading toward negative interest rates prompts questions for treasury officers managing local authority funds at LATIF. Speculation is rife that the UK… dlvr.it/Rr3Mrj pic.twitter.com/wtxYAB20PO

    Room151 1 week ago

    Will new public procurement rules offer the best commercial results?: The government has issued a green paper on reforming procurement rules. Helen Randall and Rebecca Rees examine the proposals and argue they may not go far enough. The Cabinet… dlvr.it/Rqtw6T pic.twitter.com/9GiVTkL08U

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    The vaccine may help settle cash flows but inflation remains a risk: Sponsored article: Lauren Sewell examines the prospects for long-term borrowing as Brexit settles and vaccines are deployed against Covid-19. On the 9th October 2019 Whitehall sent… dlvr.it/RqZXCr pic.twitter.com/PzgOZOGQ0k

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    ESG in liquidity: Sponsored article: Gavin Haywood looks at the integration of ESG in Federated Hermes’ money market funds. Federated Hermes has over 300 public sector clients invested in our AAA rated money[...] dlvr.it/RqZX5f pic.twitter.com/E87sBXsay8

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    New realities of investing cash and liquidity: “What to do now?”: Sponsored article: Brian Buck looks at the “unique challenge” for cash management strategies. As investors assess the ongoing impact of the pandemic on their business, levels of cash and… dlvr.it/RqVbk9 pic.twitter.com/ZElVASmEUV

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Extra finance promised by the government receives a broad welcome: Sponsored article: The financial pressures facing local authorities this year continue to pose challenges for council treasurers. While the launch of the UK’s Covid-19 vaccination… dlvr.it/RqTzTF pic.twitter.com/HCjH0pyHR5

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    A savvy approach to managing your cash: Sponsored article: Caroline Hedges examines the need for active cash management to achieve a higher than average return. Last year saw the already mountainous pile of negative-yielding debt around the[...] dlvr.it/RqTzMK pic.twitter.com/uP0RQYTJLt

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Putting alternatives at the heart of multi-asset portfolios: Sponsored article: Nick Edwardson looks at the assets that provide the “most attractive opportunities”. We believe that asset allocation is the primary driver of investment returns and that the… dlvr.it/RqQ2Qt pic.twitter.com/WLBzvRRRUQ

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Thriving in the pandemic: Avoiding the stragglers: Sponsored article: George Crowdy looks at the sectors providing opportunities for sustainable investment. Throughout much of 2020, we talked about why sustainable investing has thrived in the pandemic,… dlvr.it/RqQ2NQ pic.twitter.com/dxiPWKFsPl

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    The development of CCLA’s mental health benchmark: Sponsored article: Amy Browne examines the importance of investing in mental health in the workplace. We are living through a public health emergency in more ways than one. Physical health[...] dlvr.it/RqQ2Jx pic.twitter.com/o6yRSCX3oF

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Brexit: What the EU trade deal means for the UK economy: Sponsored article: Hetal Mehta looks at the impact of Brexit on economic prospects. Four and a half years after voting to leave the EU, on Christmas Eve the UK finally[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDt pic.twitter.com/No62srfE8h

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Cash dethroned: The quest for liquid yield: Sponsored article: Peter Hunt and George Carne ask how treasury departments can balance the need for yield and liquidity. The massive stimulus and waves of liquidity provided by central banks[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDj pic.twitter.com/05g6Zhu1kU

    Room151 2 weeks ago

    Richard Harbord: Delayed “capital determinations” make section 25 opinions a new crunch point: The severe pressure on local government budgets now means section 151 officers confront a tricky call on  whether they can make a judgement on the robustness… dlvr.it/RqLBDV pic.twitter.com/vTAbDKFzkI

    Room151 1 month ago

    PWLB Consultation: Analysis straight from Dickens: Helen Radall and Paul McDermott present a legal examination of the new PWLB borrowing rules as Charles Dickens might have imagined it. Free and easy PWLB (“Marley” to his friends)[...] dlvr.it/RnmwLq pic.twitter.com/yFxcPrQqEG

  • Categories

    • 151 News
    • Agent 151
    • Blogs
    • Chris Buss
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • Dan Bates
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Development
    • Forum
    • Funding
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O'Donnell
    • Interviews
    • Jackie Shute
    • James Bevan
    • Jobs
    • LGPSi
    • Mark Finnegan
    • Recent Posts
    • Resources
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Fitzgerald
    • Stephen Sheen
    • Steve Bishop
    • Technical
    • Treasury
    • Uncategorized
  • Archives

    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012
    • 2011
  • Previous story James Bevan: All eyes on Central Banks
  • Next story David Green: Deposit guarantees, European style

© Copyright 2021 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies from this website.OK