• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Conference
  • Events Calendar
  • Webcast151
  • MOTB
  • Log In
  • Register

Room 151

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews

Helen Randall: How commercial contracts go wrong

0
  • by Guest
  • in Development · Resources
  • — 25 May, 2017

Photo: edar/Pixabay, CC0

Shrinking budgets have put pressure on councils to be more commercial. Helen Randall provides a guide to the hidden dangers in commercial contracts.

Increasing financial pressures on most councils means they are now looking to make savings and increase revenue.  Ironically, many local authorities now find themselves in commercial and contractual arrangements which are unaffordable, fail to achieve savings targets, do not generate the anticipated revenue or are costly to terminate.  Why does this happen and what lessons can be learnt?

This usually comes down to one or more of five key issues:

  • Lack of commercial acumen or knowing what represents the market for the particular type of contract in that sector;
  • An ambiguous or over complex contract;
  • An open ended variation mechanism;
  • An overoptimistic business case;
  • A rush to complete without resolving substantive commercial or operational issues.

Contractors’ daily business involves negotiating contracts in their service sector which gives them a keen understanding of precisely what terms are “on market” — not just price, but also what is normal for indemnity limits, compensation on termination, contractual remedies, TUPE, pension liability, warranties and KPIs. However, most authorities enter major partnerships, joint ventures, outsourcings or PPP-type arrangements much less frequently.

Trophies

Some of the worst deals have been reached without support from professionals with up-to-date market expertise because the lead negotiator has wanted a trophy on their CV or to save money on fees.  Authorities can bring negligence or misfeasance claims in such circumstances, never mind the career-limiting impact of an auditor or ombudsman enquiry.  Do ensure your lawyers and other advisors have up-to-date market experience and never be afraid to interrogate their advice.

Ambiguous contracts create misunderstanding which can lead to dispute.  Particularly, when money is tight or personnel or political control change.

Well drafted contracts can be negated by inconsistent specifications, payment and performance mechanisms or the contractor’s proposals. Contractors can conceal material in schedules which can cancel the protections in the legal contract terms. Review by the lawyer who drafted the contract is a worthwhile investment to ensure your deal will deliver what you envisage and will be flexible for exit if circumstances change.

A contractor’s profit margin can be derived solely through seeking variations to the basic contract.  To ensure the contract stays within budget, the variation clause should be both sufficiently flexible to cater for foreseeable changes and rigorous enough to ensure ongoing value for money. This is important for benefits realisation or profit sharing clauses where a savvy contractor can sometimes manipulate an authority to pay much more than the original projected contract estimate.  Supplements to the variation clause can be concealed in schedules in particular, the contractor’s proposals, so these should be reviewed carefully to ensure the contractual variation clause is not overridden.

Sellers

It is a cliché that every public authority wishes to be a seller not a purchaser.  It is a legal requirement for a local authority wishing to set up a commercial company to compile a business case including cash flow.  You should undertake market research (even where entering into a joint venture with a private sector partner) to ensure a realistic assessment of business volume.

To avoid unlawful state aid, public sector support to any trading company should be at full commercial rates. Just because a business is in the public or voluntary sector does not exempt it from state aid rules. There are some local authority businesses currently trading with the benefit of unlawful state aid which private sector competitors will one day challenge.  Unlawful state aid can result in the recipient’s insolvency and a penalty on the authority.  Therefore, do ensure your business case includes commercial costings for premises, staff and other benefits and take advice on exemptions which are intricate.

No deal could be better

Councils are of course controlled by politicians who want to win elections which are preceded by purdah periods.  However, the worst deals are those where one party is up against an immoveable deadline because they then lose their bargaining power. Take time to explain to politicians why sometimes no deal is better than a bad deal.  Do scrutinise the procurement timetable for over optimistic assumptions and factor in meaningful external consultation and internal briefings.

Many authorities close competitive dialogues too early and sacrifice the bargaining power afforded by the competition between bidders.  A better long term deal can be reached where dialogue is only closed once you are certain you have driven out as much detail as possible from your bidders.

On a positive note, many good commercial deals are signed by local authorities though, sadly, these rarely make the news.  Clear contract documents negotiated by a commercially astute team who is not afraid to ask the obvious question, or to take time to get the detail right, always pay dividends in terms of savings achieved, profits shared and costly disputes prevented.

Helen Randall

Helen Randall, partner, Trowers & Hamlins LLP.

Share

You may also like...

  • Haringey signs off regeneration JV for 6,400 new homes despite protests Haringey signs off regeneration JV for 6,400 new homes despite protests 6 Jul, 2017
  • Warrington outlines robust defence of out-of-borough investments Warrington outlines robust defence of out-of-borough investments 20 Feb, 2019
  • Housing policy risks ‘sting in the tail’ as new HRA freedoms combine with Right to Buy pilot Housing policy risks ‘sting in the tail’ as new HRA freedoms combine with Right to Buy pilot 22 Nov, 2017
  • Government calls for LGPS investment in new homes Government calls for LGPS investment in new homes 9 Feb, 2017

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Latest tweets

    Room151 4 hours ago

    ‘Chasing yield’ not the best strategy as negative rates loom: Recent speculation that the UK may be heading toward negative interest rates prompts questions for treasury officers managing local authority funds at LATIF. Speculation is rife that the UK… dlvr.it/Rr3Mrj pic.twitter.com/wtxYAB20PO

    Room151 2 days ago

    Will new public procurement rules offer the best commercial results?: The government has issued a green paper on reforming procurement rules. Helen Randall and Rebecca Rees examine the proposals and argue they may not go far enough. The Cabinet… dlvr.it/Rqtw6T pic.twitter.com/9GiVTkL08U

    Room151 1 week ago

    The vaccine may help settle cash flows but inflation remains a risk: Sponsored article: Lauren Sewell examines the prospects for long-term borrowing as Brexit settles and vaccines are deployed against Covid-19. On the 9th October 2019 Whitehall sent… dlvr.it/RqZXCr pic.twitter.com/PzgOZOGQ0k

    Room151 1 week ago

    ESG in liquidity: Sponsored article: Gavin Haywood looks at the integration of ESG in Federated Hermes’ money market funds. Federated Hermes has over 300 public sector clients invested in our AAA rated money[...] dlvr.it/RqZX5f pic.twitter.com/E87sBXsay8

    Room151 1 week ago

    New realities of investing cash and liquidity: “What to do now?”: Sponsored article: Brian Buck looks at the “unique challenge” for cash management strategies. As investors assess the ongoing impact of the pandemic on their business, levels of cash and… dlvr.it/RqVbk9 pic.twitter.com/ZElVASmEUV

    Room151 1 week ago

    Extra finance promised by the government receives a broad welcome: Sponsored article: The financial pressures facing local authorities this year continue to pose challenges for council treasurers. While the launch of the UK’s Covid-19 vaccination… dlvr.it/RqTzTF pic.twitter.com/HCjH0pyHR5

    Room151 1 week ago

    A savvy approach to managing your cash: Sponsored article: Caroline Hedges examines the need for active cash management to achieve a higher than average return. Last year saw the already mountainous pile of negative-yielding debt around the[...] dlvr.it/RqTzMK pic.twitter.com/uP0RQYTJLt

    Room151 1 week ago

    Putting alternatives at the heart of multi-asset portfolios: Sponsored article: Nick Edwardson looks at the assets that provide the “most attractive opportunities”. We believe that asset allocation is the primary driver of investment returns and that the… dlvr.it/RqQ2Qt pic.twitter.com/WLBzvRRRUQ

    Room151 1 week ago

    Thriving in the pandemic: Avoiding the stragglers: Sponsored article: George Crowdy looks at the sectors providing opportunities for sustainable investment. Throughout much of 2020, we talked about why sustainable investing has thrived in the pandemic,… dlvr.it/RqQ2NQ pic.twitter.com/dxiPWKFsPl

    Room151 1 week ago

    The development of CCLA’s mental health benchmark: Sponsored article: Amy Browne examines the importance of investing in mental health in the workplace. We are living through a public health emergency in more ways than one. Physical health[...] dlvr.it/RqQ2Jx pic.twitter.com/o6yRSCX3oF

    Room151 1 week ago

    Brexit: What the EU trade deal means for the UK economy: Sponsored article: Hetal Mehta looks at the impact of Brexit on economic prospects. Four and a half years after voting to leave the EU, on Christmas Eve the UK finally[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDt pic.twitter.com/No62srfE8h

    Room151 1 week ago

    Cash dethroned: The quest for liquid yield: Sponsored article: Peter Hunt and George Carne ask how treasury departments can balance the need for yield and liquidity. The massive stimulus and waves of liquidity provided by central banks[...] dlvr.it/RqLBDj pic.twitter.com/05g6Zhu1kU

    Room151 1 week ago

    Richard Harbord: Delayed “capital determinations” make section 25 opinions a new crunch point: The severe pressure on local government budgets now means section 151 officers confront a tricky call on  whether they can make a judgement on the robustness… dlvr.it/RqLBDV pic.twitter.com/vTAbDKFzkI

    Room151 1 month ago

    PWLB Consultation: Analysis straight from Dickens: Helen Radall and Paul McDermott present a legal examination of the new PWLB borrowing rules as Charles Dickens might have imagined it. Free and easy PWLB (“Marley” to his friends)[...] dlvr.it/RnmwLq pic.twitter.com/yFxcPrQqEG

    Room151 1 month ago

    Room151’s top stories from a momentous year: 2020 was the year in which local government grappled with Covid-19, funding strains, controversy over borrowing rules and the threat of financial collapse. It has been an exhausting and historic[...] dlvr.it/RnlpZg pic.twitter.com/g3myNyox6J

    Room151 1 month ago

    Tracy Bingham: 2020, a year best forgotten but also one of learning: Many will rush to erase 2020 from their memories but, writes Tracy Bingham, there were also many lessons about finance teams, strategic planning and leadership. 2020: A year we’d… dlvr.it/RnlpY2 pic.twitter.com/m7G1krrtCu

    Room151 1 month ago

    Settlement must address ‘precarious’ local government finances: Dan Bates crosses his fingers for “no nasty surprises” in this week’s funding settlement but argues the “bigger prize” is post-Covid financial certainty. Thursday (17 December) should be the… dlvr.it/Rnj9dG pic.twitter.com/KLKjjuBqJE

  • Categories

    • 151 News
    • Agent 151
    • Blogs
    • Chris Buss
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • Dan Bates
    • David Crum
    • David Green
    • Development
    • Forum
    • Funding
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O'Donnell
    • Interviews
    • Jackie Shute
    • James Bevan
    • Jobs
    • LGPSi
    • Mark Finnegan
    • Recent Posts
    • Resources
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Fitzgerald
    • Stephen Sheen
    • Steve Bishop
    • Technical
    • Treasury
    • Uncategorized
  • Archives

    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012
    • 2011
  • Previous story Liverpool’s chief exec steps down amid fraud investigation
  • Next story Uttlesford spends £45m on science park with loan beating PWLB rates

© Copyright 2021 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies from this website.OK