• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • LATIF
  • Conferences
  • Dashboard
  • Edit My Profile
  • Log In
  • Logout
  • Register
  • Edit this post

Room 151

  • 151 BRIEF

    What's New?

  • Slough welcomes commitment that Office for Local Government ‘will not be a burden’

    June 30, 2022

  • Homes England agrees strategic partnership with two authorities

    June 29, 2022

  • Soaring inflation and pay pressures to add £3.6bn to council budgets

    June 28, 2022

  • Underfunded social care reforms could ‘exacerbate workforce pressures’

    June 27, 2022

  • Nottingham City Council leader labels proposed intervention as ‘disappointing’

    June 27, 2022

  • Government preparing to intervene in Nottingham City Council

    June 23, 2022

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews
  • Briefs

Crisis in local audit unlikely to be solved by coming reforms

1
  • by Stephen Sheen
  • in Blogs · Stephen Sheen · Technical
  • — 1 Sep, 2021

Photo by Tyler Franta on Unsplash

Local authority audit is changing but, Stephen Sheen argues, 100% private sector provision is unlikely to be “viable” while the underlying problem is difficulty recruiting for “soul destroying” work.

At the end of July, MHCLG opened a consultation on technical aspects of the local audit framework, setting out its proposals for meeting some of the recommendations of the Redmond Review. The consultation will close very precisely at 11:45pm on 22 September.

The key features are:

  • Confirmation of the intention for the FRC’s successor body, ARGA (Audit Reporting and Governance Authority) to be the system leader for local audit. As ARGA will not be operational until 2023, the FRC is planning to establish interim arrangements from April 2022, including the appointment of a lead local audit executive, the formation of a shadow local audit department, and the establishment of forums for engaging directly with local bodies and local audit firms.
  • An objective to strengthen audit committees. Consideration is being given to whether it should be a statutory requirement for local authorities to have audit committees (ACs). Alternatively, CIPFA’s  Audit Committees: Practical Guidance for Local Authorities and Police could be given the status of statutory guidance. There is particular interest in making sure audit committees have an effective position in the overall committee structure including: an ability to be heard by full council; a duty to report significant issues and knowledge, as well as provide expertise and training for members; the use of enhanced input from independent members; and facilities for auditors to meet privately with audit committees or council.
  • Amendment of the accounts and audit regulations so that auditors will be required to present their annual audit findings to full council, accompanied by an audit committee report with responses to those findings. This would take place at the first meeting of full council after the committee has considered the findings.
  • Addressing capacity issues by facilitating an increase in key audit partners (KAPs) and considering options for additional training and specialist support.

 


16 September 2021
London Stock Exchange or ONLINE
13th Local Authority Treasurers’ Investment Forum

Room151’s flagship annual conference. Free attendance for local government treasurers and section 151 officers.
Visit our conference page for more information
Lead sponsor CCLA
Public sector treasurers can register here


Private sector

Putting to one side the irony that a primary reason system leader is needed is for someone to guide the FRC in the ways of local audit (see previous columns ad nauseam), the key point to note from the proposals is that the proposals are absolutely dedicated to a model of 100% private sector provision.

But there is little evidence that such a model is viable. Suggestions for tinkering with the rules on KAPs is a strong indication that there is little prospect of the current firms being willing, or able, to maintain the pool through internal succession.

Although the Audit Commission slowed its recruitment once it knew of its abolition, the firms were gifted largely functioning audit teams when the organisation was broken up. They have been unable to sustain these teams, let alone nurture them.

The root of this problem is at the lowest level. There just isn’t the supply of people with the necessary public sector ethos who would either contemplate working for a firm in the first place or be able to survive the soul destroying life of a junior local auditor. And there is no longer an Audit Commission from which to poach part-qualified and qualified staff.

Wider brief

Part of the issue is the tight focus of the work on the audit of financial statements, the outcome of which (for good reasons—also see previous columns) nobody is particularly interested in.

Think how much more interesting the job would be if auditors were also concerned with confirming the adequacy of an authority’s financial systems to support its operations (rather than just their sufficiency to support the financial statements), confirming financial standing, reviewing arrangements for preventing fraud and corruption and ensuring the legality of transactions, agreeing the effectiveness of governance arrangements and investigating matters brought to their attention by the public? Then think that this is probably what the public would want auditors to be doing (if it hadn’t already presumed that this is what they do). But then realise that the firms have worked solidly over the years to avoid such responsibilities.

It’s a wider brief for local audit that would be of much greater value to the public, more rewarding work for auditors and includes tasks that could be undertaken throughout the year and reported on while issues are still fresh. Good value at twice the price.

I still don’t think this would be enough to make a 100% private sector solution sustainable. Thoughts must be given to how we again establish a public sector local audit capability to sustain a sufficient mass of skilled auditors.

 



Sway

In the meantime, can authorities do anything constructive? Not a lot. The price of having your auditors appointed by PSAA (Public Sector Audit Appointments) was ceding any sway over the carrying out of their work. Auditors have secured comprehensive independence, rather than just in the required area of influence over the audit opinion. This is why it could be worthwhile considering the opportunities for self-appointment discussed in Conrad Hall’s recent article.

MHCLG and PSAA have both warned authorities to be careful what they wish for if they were to step outside the PSAA arrangements. You might find the market even barer if you test it for yourself.

However, with the prize of being able to secure contractual commitments over the timing and staffing of audits and control over fees, there is good reason to investigate the possibilities. Particularly if you can join with other authorities to offer a substantial offering around which a smaller firm could build a local presence.

Stephen Sheen is the managing director of Ichabod’s Industries, a consultancy providing a technical accounting support service to local authorities. He was previously the senior technical manager for local government audit at PricewaterhouseCoopers.

Photo by Tyler Franta on Unsplash

—————

FREE monthly newsletters
Subscribe to Room151 Newsletters

Room151 Linkedin Community
Join here

Monthly Online Treasury Briefing
Sign up here with a .gov.uk email address

Room151 Webinars
Visit the Room151 channel

Share

You may also like...

  • Code revision will end ‘intentional misinterpretation’ 28th Jul, 2021
  • China’s tech giant edge 12th Jul, 2021
  • PWLB changes and local authority creditworthiness 27th Jan, 2021
  • New realities of investing cash and liquidity: “What to do now?” 13th Jan, 2021

1 Comment

  1. Ichabod’s at Room 151 – Ichabod’s Industries says:
    2021/09/01 at 16:01

    […] Crisis in local audit […]

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • 151 BRIEFS – WHAT’s NEW?

    • Homes England agrees strategic partnership with two authorities
    • Soaring inflation and pay pressures to add £3.6bn to council budgets
    • Underfunded social care reforms could ‘exacerbate workforce pressures’
    • Nottingham City Council leader labels proposed intervention as ‘disappointing’
    • Government preparing to intervene in Nottingham City Council
  • Room151’s LGPS Roundtables

    Biodiversity
    Valuations & Risk
    LGPS Women

  • Room151’s LGPS Roundtables

    Biodiversity
    LGPS Women
    Valuations & Risk
  • Latest tweets

    Room151 2 hours ago

    Hillier confirmed as keynote speaker for LATIF/FDs’ Summit: Dame Meg Hillier, chair of the Public Accounts Committee, has been confirmed as a keynote speaker for Room151’s combined Local Authority Treasurers Investment Forum (LATIF) and FDs Summit. The… dlvr.it/ST70F7 pic.twitter.com/hxV676Iley

    Room151 2 hours ago

    Councils’ funding at risk due to ‘undercounting’ in census data: Population estimates in London and Manchester may have been significantly underestimated in the 2021 census potentially threatening government funding for frontline services in these… dlvr.it/ST707J pic.twitter.com/VncIyaXa01

    Room151 2 days ago

    Gove at LGA: councils to receive two-year financial settlement: Michael Gove has announced that councils will receive a two-year financial settlement from next year to provide authorities with “financial certainty” and allow them to plan ahead. The… dlvr.it/ST0kSV pic.twitter.com/wxL3UM4sGO

    Room151 2 days ago

    LGPS valuations: the digital journey: Rob Bilton explains how technology is helping to deliver one of the most complex data exercises in the world of public sector pensions. The 2022 valuations for LGPS funds in[...] dlvr.it/ST0kMq pic.twitter.com/VxjSPC2Uvo

    Room151 6 days ago

    Conrad Hall: ‘more sophisticated’ regulation needed for local government: The chair of the CIPFA/LASAAC Code Board has questioned the sophistication of financial regulation in local government and the continuing focus of the Department for Levelling Up,… dlvr.it/SSnPBV pic.twitter.com/G5d7JCWF8c

    Room151 1 week ago

    Slough Council approves plans to restructure finance department: Slough Borough Council has approved plans to restructure its finance department to enhance capacity and capability and to address a “significant weakness” in the function. The local… dlvr.it/SSf8DG pic.twitter.com/l5lmyHmkBg

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Previous story 2021 treasury management survey underway
  • Next story LGPS could back an investment Big Bang ‘so long as the price is right’

© Copyright 2022 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

0 shares