• Home
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • LATIF
  • Conferences
  • Dashboard
  • Edit My Profile
  • Log In
  • Logout
  • Register
  • Edit this post

Room 151

  • 151 BRIEF

    What's New?

  • Slough welcomes commitment that Office for Local Government ‘will not be a burden’

    June 30, 2022

  • Homes England agrees strategic partnership with two authorities

    June 29, 2022

  • Soaring inflation and pay pressures to add £3.6bn to council budgets

    June 28, 2022

  • Underfunded social care reforms could ‘exacerbate workforce pressures’

    June 27, 2022

  • Nottingham City Council leader labels proposed intervention as ‘disappointing’

    June 27, 2022

  • Government preparing to intervene in Nottingham City Council

    June 23, 2022

  • Treasury
  • Technical
  • Funding
  • Resources
  • LGPS
  • Development
  • 151 News
  • Blogs
    • David Green
    • Agent 151
    • Dan Bates
    • Richard Harbord
    • Stephen Sheen
    • James Bevan
    • Steve Bishop
    • Cllr John Clancy
    • David Crum
    • Graham Liddell
    • Ian O’Donnell
    • Jackie Shute
  • Interviews
  • Briefs

LGPS ‘may need interim valuation’ to deal with Supreme Court fallout

0
  • by Jim Dunton
  • in 151 News · LGPS
  • — 23 Jul, 2019

Uncertainty in the wake of a Supreme Court ruling on discrimination related to public-service pension reform may require the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) to conduct an interim valuation, bosses have said.

The LGPS said it could take a year or more for an Employment Tribunal to decide on the appropriate remedy for firefighters and judges.

Both were found to have been unfairly discriminated against by the government’s 2015 changes, which introduced a cost-cap process to improve sustainability and better manage contributions and benefits to members.

The tribunal decision will apply to the pensions of local-government workers as well as civil servants, teachers, police and NHS staff.

At the heart of the discrimination were so-called “transitional protections” created to safeguard the pension entitlement of older scheme members who were due to retire within 10 years and which tapered aid for those with up to four years longer to work.

Those arrangements were ruled to be discriminatory against younger staff in an Appeal Court judgement in December, a decision that was upheld last month by the Supreme Court.

Ministers believe the impact of the decision in what is known as the McCloud case could amount to £4bn a year and will need to be backdated to 2015. 

Room151’s LGPS Asset Allocation Forum
November 7th, 2019, London Stock Exchange

Earlier this year Room151 reported comments by Michael Scanlon, deputy chief actuary in the Government Actuary’s Department, predicting LGPS funds were likely to face an increase in their liabilities of up to 1% as a result of the case.

Last week chief secretary to the Treasury, Liz Truss made a statement to parliament confirming that an Employment Tribunal would decide on the remedy in relation to firefighters and judges, and that the decision would be applied across all public sector pension schemes.

Reacting to Truss’ statement, the LGPS Scheme Advisory Board (SAB) said “significant changes” to public-service pension schemes may be required because the remedy for ending discrimination would be to raise entitlements.

The board said that there could be a “material impact” on the outcome of the cost-cap process introduced under the 2015 reforms and which has been paused because of the court case.

The board said the Employment Tribunal decision would likely require the submission of detailed evidence and could take 12 months or longer to reach a hearing, although it accepted that the judges, the Fire Brigades Union and ministers might reach an agreement beforehand.

“In either case we expect that the cost-cap process will be re-run taking into account the remedy and any scheme amendments,” it said.

The SAB added that although any benefit changes for the 2020/2021 financial year could potentially be taken account of up to March 2020, the real cut-off point was October this year because councils needed to set their budgets.

“If the changes cannot be accounted for in the 2019 valuations, then depending on their extent and cost an interim valuation may be needed to reset employer contribution certificates,” it said.

Barry McKay, associate actuary at pension adviser Barnett Waddingham, told Room151 it was “unlikely” that the remedy for countering the pensions discrimination would be known in time for it to feed into the 2019 LGPS valuation. 

“This introduces further uncertainty in the results,” he said. “Funds will need to discuss a sensible approach with their fund actuary and decide whether and how much allowance to make for any additional costs that may arise.”

McKay said fixing the discrimination would “not be straightforward”, particularly not if the remedy was to be practical and avoid unnecessarily complex future administration issues.   

“We do not want to spend more on administration than the cost of increased members’ benefits,” he said. 

“However, it is also possible that being put back into the old final salary schemes might make some members worse off, given the more generous accrual rate in the career average schemes and current low real pay growth environment. 

“In relation to the LGPS, an extension of the underpin that applies for those members within 10 years of retirement could be the solution.”

In January, MP Truss announced that the cost-cap review process, which had been due to recalculate contributions from public-sector pension scheme members with changes going live at the start of the 2019/20 financial year, was being paused because of uncertainty around the McCloud case.

At the time, public sector unions dubbed the decision a device to delay implementing a review that was expected to reduce member contributions and increase benefits.

The £4bn annual estimate cited by Truss was also viewed with scepticism. 

Get the Room 151 LGPS Quarterly Briefing

Room151 Conferences & Events

Share

You may also like...

  • LGPS webinar: Governance the key to TCFD implementation 1st Mar, 2021
  • Mixed reaction to proposed government intervention powers 19th May, 2022
  • MRP U-turn welcomed but ‘unintended consequences remain’ 20th Jun, 2022
  • LGPS: Top stories 2021 15th Dec, 2021

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • 151 BRIEFS – WHAT’s NEW?

    • Homes England agrees strategic partnership with two authorities
    • Soaring inflation and pay pressures to add £3.6bn to council budgets
    • Underfunded social care reforms could ‘exacerbate workforce pressures’
    • Nottingham City Council leader labels proposed intervention as ‘disappointing’
    • Government preparing to intervene in Nottingham City Council
  • Room151’s LGPS Roundtables

    Biodiversity
    Valuations & Risk
    LGPS Women

  • Room151’s LGPS Roundtables

    Biodiversity
    LGPS Women
    Valuations & Risk
  • Latest tweets

    Room151 4 hours ago

    Hillier confirmed as keynote speaker for LATIF/FDs’ Summit: Dame Meg Hillier, chair of the Public Accounts Committee, has been confirmed as a keynote speaker for Room151’s combined Local Authority Treasurers Investment Forum (LATIF) and FDs Summit. The… dlvr.it/ST70F7 pic.twitter.com/hxV676Iley

    Room151 4 hours ago

    Councils’ funding at risk due to ‘undercounting’ in census data: Population estimates in London and Manchester may have been significantly underestimated in the 2021 census potentially threatening government funding for frontline services in these… dlvr.it/ST707J pic.twitter.com/VncIyaXa01

    Room151 2 days ago

    Gove at LGA: councils to receive two-year financial settlement: Michael Gove has announced that councils will receive a two-year financial settlement from next year to provide authorities with “financial certainty” and allow them to plan ahead. The… dlvr.it/ST0kSV pic.twitter.com/wxL3UM4sGO

    Room151 2 days ago

    LGPS valuations: the digital journey: Rob Bilton explains how technology is helping to deliver one of the most complex data exercises in the world of public sector pensions. The 2022 valuations for LGPS funds in[...] dlvr.it/ST0kMq pic.twitter.com/VxjSPC2Uvo

    Room151 6 days ago

    Conrad Hall: ‘more sophisticated’ regulation needed for local government: The chair of the CIPFA/LASAAC Code Board has questioned the sophistication of financial regulation in local government and the continuing focus of the Department for Levelling Up,… dlvr.it/SSnPBV pic.twitter.com/G5d7JCWF8c

    Room151 1 week ago

    Slough Council approves plans to restructure finance department: Slough Borough Council has approved plans to restructure its finance department to enhance capacity and capability and to address a “significant weakness” in the function. The local… dlvr.it/SSf8DG pic.twitter.com/l5lmyHmkBg

  • Register to become a Room151 user

  • Previous story Stick or twist? De-risking vs growth assets for the fully funded
  • Next story Legal services joint venture collapses

© Copyright 2022 Room 151. Typegrid Theme by WPBandit.

0 shares